By Thomas D. Begley, Jr., CELA
A Third Party Special Needs Trust is usually used in a Medicaid context not for the benefit of the grantor of the trust, but for the beneficiary.
The grantor of the trust is typically a parent, but could be grandparent, sibling, other relative or friend. The grantor uses the grantor’s assets to fund the trust. The assets of the beneficiary cannot be used to fund a Third Party Special Needs Trust. In order for the trust to be a Special Needs Trust, the beneficiary must be disabled. Disability is usually determined ,y the fact that the beneficiary has received a Determination of Disability from the Social Security Administration and is receiving either Supplemental Security Income (“SSI”) or Social Security Disability Income (“SSDI”). The trust is designed so that the assets are not counted for Medicaid eligibility purposes. The beneficiary is then able to take advantage of the continuation of public benefits including usually SSI and Medicaid, as well as use the assets in the trust to enrich the beneficiary’s life. The trustee is given complete discretion with respect to distributions, and special needs language is used in designing the trust. Provisions made for distributions to the beneficiary during the beneficiary’s lifetime and distribution of any remaining principal and accrued income upon the death of the beneficiary.
Trustee
It is always good practice to select a professional trustee. The professional trustee has expertise with respect to public benefits law, tax Jaw, investment management, and usually has the ability to assist in navigating the disability system. Often the grantor of the trust is uncomfortable with a professional trustee, but this problem can usually be solved by appointing a family member as trust protector. The trust protector monitors the performance of the trustee and is given the authority to remove and replace the trustee. The trust protector’s power to remove and replace the trustee can be conditioned on cause, which would be defined in the trust document, or can be without cause. It is generally required that the replacement trustee be a professional with a certain amount of assets under management. In order for disability organization to qualify, the asset management limit might be as low as $50,000,000. On occasion, the grantor of the trust has worked with a financial advisor who would like to continue to be the financial advisor after the trust is established. Many professional trustees, such as Comerica Bank, have arrangements with money managers, such as Morgan Stanley or UBS, where Comerica will retain the outside money manager to invest the funds. This should be spelled out clearly in the trust document. The investment manager has an additional cost for managing the funds. The combined cost of the investment manager and the trustee usually exceeds the cost of having a professional trustee manage the funds in-house. This should be clearly understood by the client.
Alternatives to a Special Needs Trust
There a number of alternatives to Special Needs Trusts. These include the following:
Planning Considerations
Let’s examine the seven planning considerations in the context of a Third Party Special Needs Trust.
By Thomas D. Begley, Jr., CELA
Trusts for disabled individuals who have not reached age 65 and are funded with assets of the disabled person are authorized under OBRA-93.(1) The trust is for the benefit of disabled persons. The person much be under 65 at the inception of the trust. While the trust must be established and funded prior to the beneficiary attaining the age of 65, it may continue after 65. If the trust is funded with a structured settlement prior to the beneficiary attaining the age of 65, the trust remains viable even though payments from the annuity are received after age 65.
The trusts must be established by a parent, grandparent, legal guardian, or court. Curiously, they cannot be established by the disabled individual. However, there is legislation in Congress that would permit the individual beneficiary to establish his or her own trust.
By statute, transfers to the trust are not subject to the transfer of assets rules. The trust should be drafted so that the resources are unavailable. The trust should be administered in such a way that the income is not counted as income to the beneficiary.
The trust must provide that on death the funds remaining in the trust go first to reimburse Medicaid and then for the benefit of other beneficiaries.
The assets used to fund the trust must be the assets of the beneficiary, not the assets of a third party, except that a token amount is permitted to be contributed by a third party to seed the trust, i.e., S10 or S20. If a trust is funded with assets of a third party, it is considered a Third-Party Special Needs Trust and the rules are very different. Generally a Self-Settled Special Needs Trust, or First-Party Special Needs Trust is used in connection with:
When drafting a Self-Settled Special Needs Trust, it is always good practice to use a professional trustee. Family members are always well intentioned, but do not have the necessary expertise with respect to public benefits law, tax law and investments and do not know how to navigate the disability system. Family members frequently have a conflict of interest with the beneficiary. Family members are often uncomfortable in naming a professional trustee. A way to make everyone happy is to appoint family member as trust protector. The trust protector is given the authority to monitor the trustee and to remove and replace the trustee, if the trust protector is dissatisfied with the trustee’s performance. The trust protector’s power to remove and replace could be limited to cause, which would be spelled out in the trust document, or the power could be exercised without cause. If a family member serves as trust protector, it is inappropriate to provide for compensation for the family member. The document should provide that if the trust protector removes and replaces the professional trustee, the new trustee must also be a professional trustee. The professional trustee could be a corporate trustee or a disability organization. It is good practice to set a limit on the dollar amount under management by the new trustee. Fifty million dollars might be appropriate, so that disability organizations can qualify.
Established by
A Self-Settled Special Needs Trust must be established by a parent, grandparent, guardian or court. The Social Security Administration (SSA) is now taking the position that if a parent establishes a trust, they must fund the trust with 510 of the parent’s money. This position is based on a court case, Draper v. Colvi11.(2) The rationale seems to be that the person who “first funds” the trust is the establishor. If the parent signs the trust, but funds it with the personal injury settlement, inheritance, child support or alimony, then that money belongs to the beneficiary of the trust, so the court
and Social Security are taking the position that the first funding comes from the beneficiary and the beneficiary is not permitted to establish a Self- Settled Special Needs Trust.
The same rationale would apply to a trust established by a grandparent. Self-Settled Special Needs Trusts are seldom established by a guardian, because court action is required to authorize the guardian to establish the trust. As a practical matter, it is easier to simply have the court establish the trust. The judge will not want to sign the trust, so the trust document must state that the trust is approved, required and established and the judge directs another individual to sign the trust. Typically, the individual signing the trust is the parent, but the first funding doctrine does not apply, because the trust is actually being established by the court. It is not good practice to simply incorporate the trust in the court order by reference. It is important that the judge direct someone to sign the trust. If a parent or grandparent is not available, it could be any other family member or even an attorney.
In establishing any trust to be used in a Medicaid context, there are seven planning considerations:
While the above-referenced statutes do not mention irrevocability, the POMS do require that a Self-Settled Special Needs Trust be irrevocable.
The Social Security Administration requires that a Self Settled Special Needs Trust have a spendthrift clause. The purpose of this clause is to prevent the beneficiary of the trust from assigning trust assets. If the beneficiary had the right to assign the corpus of the trust the assets would be available and the trust would not qualify as a Special Needs Trust. Even though the trust contains a spendthrift provision, it is not immune from claims of the beneficiary’s creditors, unless it is established in a state that has a Domestic Asset Protection Trust statute. A First-Party Special Needs Trust is a Self-Settled Trust and, therefore, subject to claims of creditors. New Jersey does not have a Domestic Asset Protection Trust statute.
1 42 u.s.c. § 13 96p( d ) (4)( A).
2 Draper v. Colvin, DSD Civ. 12-4091-KES Ouly 10, 2013); U.S. Cou rt or Appeals 5th Cir. No. 13-2757 (Mar. 3, 2015).